In right this moment’s article, we’ll put two of the most secure automobiles from Volvo and Mercedes-Benz right into a head-to-head battle. Within the blue nook, we now have the 2007 Volvo XC90, an IIHS prime performer and the Swedish big’s prime SUV. Within the purple nook, straight from the center of Germany, stands the 2007 Mercedes-Benz S550, an ideal mix of energy and luxurious.
Each autos have an enormous demand within the second-hand market, and if you happen to’re planning to purchase one among them, a security comparability could be a wise factor to do. I’ve achieved that when buying a used automotive and landed on a Volvo; I do know, it’s nearly a cliche by now, however its fashions are the most secure on the planet! These guys put a lot deal with security, they even spend an entire web page of their Volvo XC90 handbook simply to elucidate methods to use the seatbelts!
Nevertheless, Mercedes is not any slouch both in the case of security — the German powerhouse is legendary for a lot of trade firsts, corresponding to standardizing the motive force’s facet airbag in every of its fashions from 1992 and introducing its now-famous digital stability program (ESP) in 1995. Nonetheless, does the S550 have sufficient expertise to win in opposition to its Swedish rival?
Let’s take a look!
Lively Security Programs and Crash Avoidance
Apparently, regardless of being considerably getting old fashions produced in 2007, each autos nonetheless got here with extremely subtle security options. Notably, the 2007 Volvo XC90 was the primary automobile with Roll Stability Management (RSC) to stop rollovers, a frequent downside with SUVs, leaping into motion as quickly because it detects a change within the lateral inclination. It then engages the brakes and lowers the engine’s torque to assist the automobile regain traction and stability. Nevertheless, the security measures don’t cease there; if every part fails and a overturn can’t be prevented, the occupants are additionally protected by a sturdy security cage, security belt tensioners, and inflatable curtains.
The 2007 XC90 additionally packs digital stability management, traction management, and 4-wheel disc brakes — however that’s solely the tip of the iceberg. If you’d like in-depth specs and an in depth listing of security options, seek the advice of your 2007 Volvo XC90 house owners handbook (there’s merely an excessive amount of to listing all of them right here). Misplaced your proprietor’s handbook or it merely didn’t come along with your used XC90? Check out eManualOnline — they’ve acquired manuals for just about any automotive mannequin ou there!
However, the Mercedes-Benz S550 options the automaker’s signature PRE-SAFE system that prepares the passengers for an impending collision. It makes use of cleverly positioned sensors to detect irregular brake pedal utility and steering wheel enter patterns and readies the sedan to embrace the affect. Measures embrace tensioning the seatbelts, inflating the facet bolsters, and adjusting the seats for higher airbag effectiveness.
In fact, being costlier than the 2007 Volvo XC90, the S550 additionally packs further options. As an example, the producer additionally affords emergency braking help, tire strain monitoring, and digital brakeforce distribution.
However does having extra security options make it any safer than the Volvo XC90? Let’s see about that within the following part.
What Do the Crash Checks Say?
The 2007 Volvo XC90 is a prime performer and has persistently ranked as one of many most secure SUV nameplates on the market. Certainly, the IIHS gave the 2007 Volvo XC90 the best “Good” ranking for frontal offset and rear-ended collisions. Additionally it is one of many few fashions to get a Good ranking for cover in opposition to whiplash accidents.
Moreover, the XC90 boasts the best ranking in different essential crash exams outcomes, corresponding to side-impact collision and driver head safety. And this isn’t stunning — studying my 2007 Volvo XC90 handbook, I discovered that the SUV has two frontal and two facet airbags upfront and two air curtains alongside the facet home windows, together with the third row!
In the meantime, the Mercedes-Benz S550 retains up with the XC90 in frontal crash exams. The S550 additionally will get a “Good” ranking for head, neck, and chest damage prevention in frontal crash exams. Nevertheless, it falls behind within the facet crash check rankings, solely securing an “Common” ranking.
Furthermore, the XC90 is loads higher in stopping damage to an occupant’s head, neck, pelvis, torso, and legs throughout a facet affect, serving to it bag an general “Good” ranking. In distinction, the S550 solely manages “Medium” and “Common” rankings for a similar.
Lastly, it’s additionally essential to say that the 2007 Volvo XC90 is an IIHS High Security Decide within the midsize luxurious SUVs section. Mercedes-Benz additionally had the 2007 M-class SUV alongside the XC90 as the highest security choose of the 12 months; nonetheless, its S-Class didn’t make the minimize. The S550 was overwhelmed by a less expensive 2007 Volvo S80 and the Audi A6 within the giant luxurious sedan section.
So regardless of being the costlier and tech-laden automobile, the S550 pales in comparison with the Volvo XC90 in the case of security. The Swedish SUV nonetheless holds on to its title and has change into a private favourite of the IIHS.
Stability and Rollover
Though the XC90 comes with a complicated security system to stop rollovers, it’s nonetheless an SUV with a excessive heart of gravity. As such, it managed a 4-star rollover ranking by the NHTSA with a 17.9% rollover threat. Nevertheless, the S500, being a sedan with a a lot decrease heart of gravity, is rather more secure, even with none security system — easy physics right here.
So, which of the 2 is safer? We must facet with the Volvo XC90 on this one. And though each autos fall into completely different classes, the 2007 XC90 comes out as superior, boasting higher security rankings. The Mercedes-Benz S550 packs many extra options and security programs, however the XC90 nonetheless does a greater job with nearly half the tech. As well as, the IIHS and NHTSA have given the 2007 XC90 their highest accolades in varied crash testing classes, whereas the S550 falls brief in a number of areas.
These are solely among the the reason why I selected the 2007 XC90 as my every day driver, however maintaining your automobile in test is much more essential for security. Notably, it is best to at all times care for the braking system; I modified my brake pads utilizing an XC90 service handbook I bought on-line, and it saved me fairly a bit of cash. I even purchased an OBD-II scanner to watch if all security programs work correctly. You can too have this achieved at your native mechanic store, however be ready to pay extra. Nonetheless, all within the title of security!